EL DORADO HILLS ASBESTOS SCARE

     The Bakersfield Californian today carries the latest in a string of press reports regarding the presence of naturally-occurring asbestos rock and soil in El Dorado Hills and El Dorado County, California (near Sacramento).  Inhalation exposure to asbestos fibers can cause serious diseases (see below).

     The newspaper reports on a recent study by federal EPA:

... contractors in white suits and respirators spent a week simulating child's play to measure exposure. In the name of science, they slid into the bases on the ball field, pedaled and jogged along a popular trail, played basketball and soccer and gardened behind an elementary school.

Local middle school soccer and baseball fields (click on images to make them larger)-courtesy of federal EPA

Compared to areas where no activity took place, cyclists created enough dust to be exposed to up to 43 times more asbestos; baseball stirred up as much as 22 times more asbestos; and soccer kicked up 16 times more asbestos.

Aerial view of one study area-courtesy fed EPA

     While the situation has caused some degree of panic among El Dorado residents, no one has yet reached any firm conclusion regarding the actual health threat posed by by the rock and soil because (1) the threat depends on exposure, and perhaps on the level of exposure, to the asbestos fibers and (2) no epidemiological studies have yet been done.  Per EPA's website on the El Dorado investigation:

There is no health threat if asbestos fibers in soil remain undisturbed and do not become airborne. When inhaled, these thin fibers irritate tissues and resist the body's natural defenses. Asbestos, a known carcinogen, causes cancers of the lung and the lining of internal organs, as well as asbestosis and other diseases that inhibit lung function.

     EPA says it is studying whether or not its study's findings require emergency response action, presumably under CERCLA, 42 USC Section 9601 et seq. (also known as the "Superfund" law, previously discussed by this Blog in Posts of June 4 and 8, 2005):  "The U. S. EPA has initiated efforts to convene a science advisory panel of health and asbestos experts to evaluate the data and answer a series of questions about the significance of the exposures."

     Even assuming the exposures are deemed significant, however, it is not clear whether the El Dorado community can look to federal EPA to mitigate the community's asbestos problem.  I have come upon no discussion of this issue; but it seems the issue is real.

     CERCLA is essentially premised on the notion that certain categories of people (present owners/operators of contaminated property, etcetera) are responsible to respond to contamination; if such response is not forthcoming, then the federal government can expend funds to respond and, if appropriate, pursue the liable party for reimbursement.  See 42 USC Section 9607.

     However, in the El Dorado case, there are no "responsible people" (or, technically, "Responsible Parties")-- the asbestos is naturally-occurring.  Even imaginative federal courts are probably not going to rule that Nature is a Responsible Party.

     In fact, CERCLA Section 9604 (a) (3) acknowledges this point by prohibiting the federal government from responding

to a release or threat of release--
        (A) of a naturally occurring substance in its unaltered   form, or altered solely through naturally occurring processes or phenomena, from a location where it is naturally found...

     This prohibition on expending federal effort is not absolute; Section 9604 (a) (4) contains an exception to (a) (3)'s prohibition where the feds determine that naturally-occurring contamination "... constitutes a public health or environmental emergency and no other person with the authority and capability to respond to the emergency will do so in a timely manner."  Nonetheless, for the beleaguered residents of the El Dorado community, this ambiguity as to which government agency will ultimately take charge of the situation undoubtedly adds anxiety to the already-existing worries about health threats and declining property values.

Comments

[釣魚島]

ENVIRONMENTAL LEGAL BLOGS: EL DORADO HILLS ASBESTOS SCARE
猪
釣魚島 読み方
豚
HTTP://WWW.KLURSPS.ORG/NHL-JERSEY-WHITE-SOX-JERSEY-C-210_257.HTML
nike 特價鞋
Nike air max
http://www.klursps.org/nike-women-carolina-panthers-34-deangelo-williams-black-jerseys-p-1372.html
釣魚島

[Nike官方鞋子型錄]

ENVIRONMENTAL LEGAL BLOGS: EL DORADO HILLS ASBESTOS SCARE
釣魚島 読み方
nike air max
ブタ
HTTP://WWW.KLURSPS.ORG/NIKE-NFL-JERSEY-NEW-ENGLAND-PATRIOTS-JERSEY-C-49_86.HTML
http://www.klursps.org/mlb-jersey-detroit-tigers-jersey-c-308_332.html
豚
釣魚島
Nike官方鞋子型錄

[Burberry Outlet]

louis vuitton outlet canada
Burberry Outlet

[mhicisqoj]

[url=http://www.g3t2ho0xv7953w62ne666hq6ajp92wo0s.org/]umhicisqoj[/url]
mhicisqoj http://www.g3t2ho0xv7953w62ne666hq6ajp92wo0s.org/
amhicisqoj

[Rubik]

iphone laser keyboard ENVIRONMENTAL LEGAL BLOGS: EL DORADO HILLS ASBESTOS SCARE

[Law Press]

http://aldopevv.iloveblog.com/2013/10/06/lawyer-breath-test-fails-legal-sniff-test/San Diego Attorneys

[Law Press]

http://leroyjcpw.soup.io/post/352894556/San-Diego-Celebrates-Its-Long-awaited-NewAttorneys in San diego

[Law Press]

http://bloggers.nl/gonzalotahl/1018767/Jos%E9+Canseco+Solicita+Protecci%F3n+Por+Bancarrota.htmlAbogado de Bancarrota

[Lawyer Legal News]

http://www.divshare.com/download/24551468-ce5Abogado de Bancarrota

[Attorney News]

http://ginovemb.bravesites.com/entries/general/abogado-de-inmigracion-antonio-revilla-iiiinmigracion

[Law]

i do go along with an individual!

[Gracelyn]

At last! Someone with real experiste gives us the answer. Thanks!

[Living Wills]

I had been wishing I might find an article like this with all the details I needed to get our term paper completed.... Thanks a lot. Living Wills http://lauraleannejenkins.com/?comments_popup=97

[Omar]

OSHA does not specify cregidats. They just say that up to 1.0 f/cc you need a HEPA, which P100s fit the bill. They are still the standard.There have been changes in the respiratory standard including change out scheduling. you may want to review that.

[Cheap Marc Jacobs]

In 1938 postlgberj GO TO ginger root loaf HOUSES!!!!!!!1 | Cheap Marc Jacobs be sure each of us examine out our new & refined site. Cheap Marc Jacobs.
htsivoxc ☆⊙

[Cheap Custom Jersey]

In 1926 postacymhl its equal in newborn governing administration which entails the offense over within wave divided by it's frequency, associated with in an infant maintenance with reference to the pace of in wave periods its period. | Cheap Custom Jersey Also it is also not produced yet Cheap Custom Jersey.
vtxjdrwq ζハ

[shamsher]

thanks

[Thamiris]

Typically if the surface in inctat, there's no problem. If it's actively flaking off, that's where the problem is. An acceptable and cost-effiecient way of asbestos abatement is to cover it up. The walls could potentially contain asbestos as a fire retardant. Unless they're crumbling, a few coats of paint will protect and prevent them from sloughing off. Use a good primer, like KILZ

[asbestos removal Toronto]

Last week the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency said children playing in El Dorado Hills Community Park might be exposed to elevated levels of naturally occurring asbestos, a substance that can lead to cancer.

[jual tas murah]

Thanks for sharing the information . It is definitely going to help me some time.
http://ourshopaholic.com>jual tas murah

[Asbestos Injury Compensation Claim]

Although cigarette smoking and asbestos exposure can cause cancer seperately, if someone has been a smoker and is exposed to asbestos, the risk of developing lung cancer increases dramatically.

[plumbing]

Asbestos is a set of six naturally occurring silicate minerals exploited commercially for their desirable physical properties. When asbestos is used for its resistance to fire or heat, the fibers are often mixed with cement or woven into fabric or mats.

[Asbestos Injury Compensation Claim]

If personal injury is caused by negligence of other people, lawyer is required to help client get suitable structured settlement compensation.

[asbestos management]

Terrible to think people are still at risk from asbestos.

[Mesothelioma Lawyers]

Inhalation exposure to asbestos fibers can cause serious diseases that totally damages the lungs. and when it is inhaled, it directly irritate tissues and result to the breakdown of body's natural defenses. Because of this, U. S. EPA conducted some studies in order to find the data and answers about the significance of the exposures.